Trend-following

Intro

Putting 100% of your portfolio in stocks is usually not wise. Although the long-term trend is up, there are occasional sharp drawdowns (in 2001, 2008). A wise thing to do is to diversify portfolio in different asset classes (stocks, bonds, commodities, REITs).

This is a concept similar to what CTAs (Commodity Trading Advisors) have been doing for decades already. At present it is probably more popular under a Global Tactical Asset Allocation (GTAA).

The concept is simple:

  • All the asset classes are added to the portfolio inversely proportionally to their risk (risk-parity), so that each asset contributes the equal amount of risk into portfolio.
  • You do not hold all the assets at all times. Each asset’s weight is either what we have from point 1 (risk parity weight), or 0. This depends whether the asset is trending up or not.

To use a GTAA concept, you have to choose GTAA in the Universe selection section (which is only available for PAID ACCOUNT).

Let us have a look at the efficiency of using simple moving average filter for each asset class.

In the following graphs, there is a comparison of an asset class with the 12-month moving average applied to the class. In all cases the drawdowns are visually smaller, although the absolute return does not always have to beat the original asset.

S&P 500 Index

MSCI Europe, Australasia and Far East Index

10-year US Treasuries

Investment Grade Bond Index

Goldman Sachs Commodity Index

Gold Spot

REITs Index

In the following graphs, there is a comparison of an asset class with the 12-month moving average applied to the class. In all cases the drawdowns are visually smaller, although the absolute return does not always have to beat the original asset.

Aggregate Portfolio vs. S&P 500 Index


SPY AGG PORTFOLIO
annualized return 9.8% 7.1%
total profit 967.37% 468.35%
annualized volatility 14.55% 4.83%
sharpe ratio 0.67 1.47
maximum drawdown -50.79% -5.58%
calmar ratio 0.19 1.27
95th percentile drawdown -37.86% -3.94%
average drawdown -9.68% -0.88%
median drawdown -3.56% -0.08%
total months 304 304
no up months 193 210
no down months 111 94
% up months 63.49% 69.08%
% down months 36.51% 30.92%
best month 11.43% 4.75%
worst month -16.51% -5.58%
minimum exposure 100.0% 100.0%
maximum exposure 100.0% 100.0%
average exposure 100.0% 100.0%